Friday, May 13, 2022

FIF#158-Ergo Proxy

Romdo City: the Domed City and the last refuge of Humanity.  In a society slowly eating itself alive, a series of Android malfunctions leads to murder and a new breed of monster roams the streets: The Proxy.  Enter Re-L Mayer, a beautiful investigator assigned to the Proxy cases.  However, her investigation hits wall after wall and questions lead to more questions.  Re-L’s only lead is a young Immigrant named Vincent Law.  Together, they work to uncover the secret of the Proxys.  However, it is a secret that could push the tepid peace in Romdo City right over the edge and into utter chaos.
 
At first glance, Ergo Proxy looks like something that should be right up my alley: a futuristic dystopia featuring a sexy investigator who looks into matter involving Androids or Cyborgs with a hint of deep existential examinations.  As a life long fan of Blade Runner and Ghost in the Shell, I should be eating this kind of scifi Anime up no problem.  Buuuuut Ergo Proxy isn’t the easiest show to get into in its first episode.  And a big problem right away is one question: WHAT THE F*** IS GOING ON!!!???  Oh, I don’t mean that from a “this plot makes no sense” standpoint (even though it doesn’t).  I mean that from a visual standpoint.  Ergo Proxy is so damn dark I feel like you have to watch it with the lights out just to get the full experience.
 
I’m all for avant garde style when it comes to Anime.  There are plenty of shows that step away from the visual norm most associated with Anime and are better remembered because of it: Gankutsuou: The Count of Monte Cristo; Puella Magi Madoka Magica and FLCL come first to mind.  The difference is where those examples were vibrant and lively, Ergo Proxy is cold and lacking in color.  It’s not totally devoid of it but its rarely seen, mostly in Re-L’s cute blue eyeliner.  Most of the action is blotted out in total darkness and there are segments where Re-L is investigating a crime scene and the tint is so great that squinting hardly does you any favors.  I get it, this is supposed to be a dystopia, it’s hardly the most exciting place to be.  But even basic storytelling dictates show don’t tell and we’re hardly shown anything to visually associate with the heavy handed exposition that means nothing because I hardly understand what’s going on, much less can see it all.
 
Re-L herself has a sexy design when she’s standing in the light and you can tell she’s got shades of Ghost in the Shell’s leading lady, Major Motoko Kusinagi, inspiring her creation.  She’s a keen investigator, has a way with existential introspection, and carries a shotgun she can wield with one hand.  Re-L even has her own Android companion, Iggy, who reminds me of K-2SO from Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, minus the snark.  There’s an immediate mystery laid out for her right away, mostly pertaining to her being related to one of Romdo City’s ruling hierarchs and a constant need to keep key investigation details hidden from her. But again, the darkness that visually compromises this series keeps thing hidden from the viewer as well.  So as much that even if Re-L is quite cute to look at, I don’t think I wanna strain myself to look at what that show wants to keep away for the sake of being, idk artsy.
 
That’s a shame because I’ve had Ergo Proxy on my radar for a while.  However, this is probably the first Anime i’ve ever watched where the visuals are the toughest thing to deal with because you cant see squat.  For all the Blade Runner-isms, the Big-O esque setting and Re-L looking good while solving mysteries, Studio Manglobe really screwed such promise with such a risky visual approach.  As Roy Batty said in Blade Runner, “Ive seen things you people wouldn’t believe.” Apparently so has Ergo Proxy but unlike Batty, it wants to tease us mercilessly without so much of a hint as to those amazing things.

No comments:

Post a Comment