Chaos envelopes the Earth Sphere as Kycillia enacts her
Coup d’etat to seize total control of Zeon from her family and finish the Earth
once and for all. Unaware of the
destruction she’s causing, Nyaan continues to obey Kycillia, desperate to find
Shuji. Standing in her way is Machu, who is determined to save the Lalah from
another world any way she can. As the
former friends cross swords, their mutual wishes are on the verge of being
granted…though doing so may bring about the end of their world.
By the time we get to the final moments of Mobile Suit
Gundam GQuuuuuX my biggest question is: Why?
Why is this show so short?
Why is
it so poorly written?
Why were any of
the creative choices given a greenlight and, amongst so many others, Why is
this the result of a team up between Studio Sunrise and Studio Khara?
Most of last weeks penultimate episodes felt
like a soft reboot of the shows status quo with a lot of potential for Nyaan
and even Machu…ok maybe not Machu but maybe for the new UC at large.
However that might’ve meant something and
could have resulted in a Gundam ZZ type of creative comeback…if this wasn’t
twelve episodes long.
The only thing
that would make this mess of a finale more poetic is if we had that clip of the
main cast running in the intro and just have them trip and collapse over one
another, it’s the most fitting image of GQuuuuuX in general.
Episodes 10-12 feel like a mad race to the finish line,
like the writers suddenly realized how much time they wasted with Machu’s
immature antics and Clan Battle and didn’t really know how to wrap everything
up.
Even the start of Episode 10 feels
like we’ve jumped ahead an indeterminate amount of time, to the point where
Machu’s getting trained by Chalia Bull and Nyaan’s being mentored by Kycilia
and trained by Xavier.
The conversations
between all parties feel more natural and less aggressive for the most part but
it’s all off screen developments that have led to this point so, oh well for
actual character development (we’ll come back to that later).
Once all the final pieces are in place, it’s basically
like pulling that piece of the Jenga tower that causes the whole thing to
collapse.
The long awaited civil war
between Zabi siblings…over in like two minutes, maybe even less.
Ghiren literally just shows up and dies in
that amount of time thanks to a gas attack from Kycilia, though I’ll admit I
did love it when Ghiren’s secretary suddenly started choking with Kycilia looking
at her.
It was like one of Darth Vader’s
many force chokes from Star Wars (“I find your lack of faith
disturbing.”).
Anyway, hi Ghiren, bye
Ghiren. Then it was just mindless and destinationless Mobile Suit combat that
was loud and everywhere.
Blow up the
Earth?
Oh there’s Char?
Shuji’s back…and wants to destroy the
world?
Going back to the Jenga analogy,
this was like pointing at all of the pieces hitting the ground in order and
writing down what story ideas they contained and just running with it.
I’ve written College Essays with less than 24
hours til the due date and still had plenty of coherency.
Sigh, guess we should break down some of the bigger
points.
The first half of the “plot”
revolved around Kycilia cleaning house with the newly built Yomagn’tho
Cannon.
It certainly looked apocalyptic
enough seeing A Boa A Qu getting sucked into a vortex of destruction (complete
with water gurgling sound when all was said and done).
And after all that grief about Ghiren
ordering the Colony drop on Austrailia, she wants to use the cannon to wipe out
the Earth in its entirety, cause why not.
Powering this cannon was Nyaan, who was so blinded by her desire to find
her precious “Shu-Chan” she didn’t even bother questioning anything until after
she fired the big gun that claimed thousands of lives in an instant.
But hey if it gets you closer to the guy
who’s never been into you, you be you Nyaan.
You’d think things would get somewhat better with the
return of Char.
And while he is one of
the more tolerable characters in the finale, his appearance is when things
really start flying off the rails.
Not
only does he get a Magical Girl transformation into his Zeon uniform (mask and
all), Shuji comes back and reveals the truth: this Alternate UC is the result
of Lalah going nuts when Char got killed by Amuro in another reality.
It’s reminiscent of the Marvel Comics even
“House of M” when the Scarlet Witch went insane and recreated reality to where
her lost children were still around and Mutants were the dominant species on
Earth.
But apparently Lalah has done
this multiple times judging from the red colored display of Mobile Suits
because Char doesn’t usually last very long and she just wants him to
live.
Now I’ve seen a lot of Newtype
miracles and shenanigans in Gundam but creating not just one alternate universe
but an entire freaking Multiverse of Madness?
You want an example of this kind of plot done right, go watch Puella
Magi Madoka Magica.
Oh but we weren’t even close to being done.
Char wants to send Lalah back to where she
came from to protect her.
But Shuji
wants to kill her to destroy this universe and stop Lalah from causing further
chaos.
To add insult to injury, he even
brings his own variant of the original RX-78-2 Gundam which can grow to an
Angel Rei Kaiju sized mecha because WHY THE F NOT AT THIS POINT!!!???
It’s like the writers and animators didn’t
have a proper finale in mind and just went for pure nonsensical spectacle and thinking
if it looks good, it’ll mask the imperfections…they failed.
Machu and Nyaan make up as quickly as they
started fighting and Shuji just screws off to somewhere else after Machu
declares her love for him and I don’t buy any of it.
The “romance” between Machu and Shuji has
been as dull and uninteresting as the characters themselves.
It also feels like hundreds are dying out
there just so these two and Nyaan can settle their feelings for each
other.
Not quite the usual finale for a
Gundam series but then again The Witch from Mercury was about Suletta trying to
make her Mother see the error of her ways and let go of her vengeance.
The difference: I gave much more of a damn
about Suletta and even Prospera compared to three teenagers with zero
personality and likeablity.
And last, but certainly not least: there’s Chalia Bull,
who finally gets his reunion with his long lost buddy Char.
Bear with me: There’s a scene in the movie
Madagascar where best friends Alex the Lion and Marty the Zebra are reunited on
a beach after falling off a boat.
They
run towards each other, the Chariots of Fire music is playing and they look so
happy to see each other.
Midway through,
Alex’s face changes from happy to pissed off while Marty looks confused.
Then Alex growls and Marty turns to run
saying “OH SUGAR HONEY ICE TEA!!!”
That’s Chalia and Char, particularly when Chalia suddenly reveals hes
been looking for Char just to kill him so Sayla can take over Zeon.
WHAT THE F!!!!!!!????
All this time, it’s been as if Chalia Bull’s
been pining for Char like a long lost lover and while he has made it clear the
Zabis aren’t fit to run Zeon, when the hell was Sayla ever brought up as a
candidate to replace them?
The only time
we’ve seen her before her quick cameo in the finale is during her flashback
encounter with Char on Solomon.
Jeez,
Chalia Bull might be one of the worst Char clone characters in any Gundam
series and YES I can call him that because it’s very hard to see but he is
wearing a literal Char mask while watching over Sayla (hi Ramba Ral) with
Xavier and Comoli.
Man, it has been a long time since I’ve been this heated
and riled up writing a review.
Was there
anything, ANYTHING good about these last three episodes?
Ehhhhh…bits and pieces but nothing amounting
to much.
Seeing Xavier fight Chalia Bull
was a long time coming.
Kycilia’s
killing of Ghiren and his entourage while quick was a fun moment for her.
I do like that Char and Lalah seem to get a
happy ending, better them than anyone else in this series.
Oh and I do like the crew of the Sodon and
want them in a better series.
I liked
their repartee and camaraderie on the bridge and I’d rather be hanging around
them in the middle of a warzone than the guy who thinks he knows
everything.
Poor Comoli though, she was
totally wasted in this entire series and just around for visual eye candy than
an actual character.
She deserves way
more than to just be a constantly questioning shadow behind Chalia Bull all the
time.
Alright, now that I’ve rambled and ranted through that
mess of an ending, time for Final Thoughts.
I know there are many people who like Mobile Suit Gundam GQuuuuuX, who
love how freaking insane and crazy places it goes but I am not one of
them.
Every promising step forward has
taken 100 gigantic steps backwards.
Every potential storyline, fumbled.
Every promising character, ruined in many ways (or just never got interesting
to begin with).
The best parts I had
zero problem with were the flashbacks and explorations of the new One Year War,
complete with classic music, and those felt like they were the show everyone
wanted to be working on and not anything in the present.
Machu, Nyaan and Shuji pissed me off the more
they were around and are some of the weakest leads in a Gundam series: no
character arc, no direction, and a love triangle that Macross can outclass in
its sleep.
The animation is fine though
the Mobile Suits vary in the quality of their designs.
The action is fine as well but it’s mostly used
as a failed distraction attempt to keep watchers from realizing there’s no
reason to care about what’s happening to anyone involved in said action.
This show had so much promise with the
creative powers involved.
At the end of
the day, the Alternate One Year War and Char return setup was just a ploy to
get butts in seats and smokescreen for a show that wants to be a darker FLCL
with bigger Mecha (FLCL Season 2-3?), without any sense of direction, character
or even purpose than to just be a run of the mil Mecha series with the Gundam
name attached to it.
Been a looonnng
time since a Gundam series has pissed me off this much.
Mobile Suit Gundam GQuuuuuX receives a 3/10, which a
score a show with this much talent and power behind it should not be
getting.
And with that out of the way, onto happier things,
hopefully.
Time to wash off the stink of
GQuuuuuX with a return trip to the Best Hotel in Hell as we close out 2025 with
Hazbin Hotel (Season 2), tomorrow right here at the Gundam Anime Corner.
“Now, think about this…this is all about Neil…”
ReplyDeleteThat I think sums up my thoughts about this finale. Like, so this whole thing has been about…uh Shuji, wait no Char, huh, multiverse hopping Layla? Beyond all the other insanity you mentioned like, who was this series actually about? You’d think it’d be about finding Char but no, it’s actually about space-and-time wrapping Layla cause she’s sad Char ‘dies’ in the end so many times? And Shuji for some damn reason wants to kill her? WHY? What did she do to him, did she alter his world and ruin it? What is his motivation beyond stopping the madness (Which if that entitled stopping this show from existing then YES do it!)
And then on top of that, like there’s just no satisfaction from trying to resolve the Zeon Civil War stuff. Like, Kycilia’s killing of Ghiren could have been immensely satisfying had he been an actual foil of this series. I really think they’re just trying to use his reputation as a character, as to why you should be satisfied when she kills him. However, in this series, there was no build up to that. Like again with The Man in the High Castle, John Smith’s final decapitation of the Nazi hierarchy (with him nicely ironically killing Himmler with Zyklon Gas) is the build up of like the whole series and his scheming to survive and grow in power. Thus, even though he’s an antagonist, you do feel like ‘yeah fuck yeah’ when he just takes out all the old Nazis.
You don’t get any of that in this because Kycilia is barely a character and Ghiren is SIR BARELY APPEARING IN THIS FILM. Like even in Star Wars the Emperor is mentioned in 4, introduced in 5, and the main villain of 6. Like he gets most of his build up in Jedi, but he’s still key to the story and thus when Vader tosses his ass down that shaft, you’re thrilled to see the evil prune face get what he deserves.
I think a 12-episode series can work, but not if you waste so much god-damn time on things that don’t matter to the story. The Clan battles, the useless love triangle, the unnecessary introduction of Multiverse crap. Somebody dropped the ball with this one, and it clearly shows. I can’t even say it’s trying to use nostalgia bait to be successful, cause like it seems the Alt-One Year War stuff was the only thing they put real effort into, but its so minimal to the series.
If I was writing this, I’d basically have it focus on three main things.
One, explore the post-war rule through the eyes of the characters. Have at least 2-4 be direct ones who were in the One Year War, with maybe 1 or 2 as main supporting characters and others as supporting or one shot characters. A new character who is our POV character and can get caught up in events and be supported by those veterans. And then touch base with characters from OG series who would make sense to see, if it adds to the story OR you can tell a good story with them.
Two, the main plot driving items would be, an internal Zeon power struggle. A mystery of what happened to Char/Gundam in the war. And maybe the brewing tension between Earth and Zeon, as they compete Cold War style, to get the Neutral Sides to pick a side in the coming ‘Round 2.’
Finally, you show how the alternate One Year War played out with some flashbacks woven into the story, related to the supporting characters, and as our main character maybe discovers stuffs too.
12 episodes wouldn’t be a lot to do all that, but if you managed things well I think you could. Probably 24 would be better though.
This one was stinker at the end of the day, and the only way I can end my thoughts is….and it’s going to be a big one…
“CHAR!!!!!!!!!!!”