Though they have won their High School Tankery
Tournament, the Tankery Team of Ooarai Girls High School are devastated to
learn that their beloved school is to be closed for good. As Miho and the others begin to imagine lives
apart from one another, a last ditch deal is struck. If the Ooarai High girls can defeat a college
level Tankery Team in a Team Deathmatch style showdown, Ooarai High will remain
open. Their opponents: The University
Strengthened Team, led by a prodigy as skilled as Miho, Alice Shimada. Against overwhelming odds and with the fate
of their school on the line, Miho, Saori, Hana, Yukari and Mako will have to
call in every favor they have and prepare for the ultimate battle.
Girls und Panzer is a strange series but dammit it works
and it works so well.
The idea of cute
High School Girls operating vintage World War II tanks in an actual school
sport proved to be a hidden gem for me (does it count as a Sports Anime, cause
I do find I have soft spots for those).
Having just finished up the TV Series, I wasn’t sure what to expect from
the Girls und Panzer movie, more of the same just meant to be seen on a bigger
screen I guess.
Well there’s a lot of
retreading and underutilization when it comes to the story and the characters,
old and new.
When it comes to the
action, well you know half of you are here for the tank mayhem (1/4
th
are also here for the girls and another 1/4
th are here for both in
equal measure) and damn if you thought that you got plenty of the good stuff in
the TV Series, Tankery has never looked or sounded better than it does here.
As a life long Anime fan, I’m used to Movies based on TV
Series to rehash and even recycle familiar plots over and over again, look no
further than Shonen Films for that (looking directly at you Dragon Ball
Z).
I never expected Girls und Panzer to
take the same approach and so soon.
We
just finished a series long arc where Miho and her Tankery Club had to win
their High School Tankery Tournament to keep the doors of their school open.
And yet right after the impressive opening
skirmish, we’re right back to that same plot once more, only this time Ooarai
is actually closed and we get to see the girls relocated from their home.
It feels both lazy on the part of the writers
and unfair to the cast of likable girls who basically threw in all of that hard
work for nothing.
There’s plenty of
moments to see Miho and the others come together once more to make the most of
their new situation and relish in the time they’ve had as comrades in arms.
But seriously, why make this the setup when
you know Ooarai will be open again by the time the credits roll?
The other downside to the film is the Tankery Teams’ main
opponent, Alice Shimada and the University Strenghthed Team.
While we never got to know all of the Ooarai
teams indepth, there was enough quirkiness and distinction between them where
they all stood out in their own way.
Alice’s crew is just another bunch of holier than thou Tank Girls who
are so overconfident its annoying.
Alice
herself isn’t given any character development or motivations beyond taking on
Miho, who happens to be a fan of the same Punchy Bear that Miho has a plushy of
during the series.
One off antagonists
can be tough to pull off but I don’t think any effort was made for Alice beyond
making her look as cute as the rest of the cast.
She and Miho only have one very brief
interaction before the big match and that’s all.
She definitely lacks the personal connection
Miho had with her sister, Maho, during the course of the TV Show and they get a
nice little team up arc in this movie.
There’s one more part of The Movie that doesn’t work for
me but to get to it, we’ve gotta talk about the good stuff: the Tankery.
Girls und Panzer der Film was made for a big
screen experience and steps up its game big time from the TV Show.
That characters poking out from the tanks
look much improved from how they did before and the sound design has been
cranked up.
When those tanks fire
shells, the sound system rumbles and it is awesome.
The Movie even brings in much more first person
perspective sequences to the party.
The
added line of sight puts viewers up close and personal with the action, making
a wild ride even wilder.
There’s a scene
where one tank finds itself on a roller coaster track and once the camera sets
itself at the front of the tank, you can feel that drop when it happens.
The big battle between Ooarai and it’s allies
and the University Strengthened Team goes on for a good chunk of the movie,
almost half of the two hour runtime…and besides the slight negatives I have
about some things, I never once got tired of the tank battling goodness.
No, my problem comes with…well, the handling of the
cast.
Many of Ooarai’s opponents turned
friends from the TV Series return to back up Miho and the gang and rebuff their
numbers.
And it’s great to see fan
favorites like Saunders Team Leader Kay and my personal favorite, Tiny Stalin
Katyusha, back in action, we spend a lot of time with these tank teams, maybe
too much.
A brand new Japanese team that
has a habit of charging in without a plan is also introduced and they get a
fair amount of screentime too.
At one
point I asked myself, “Whens the last time we’ve seen Miho, Saori, Hana, Yukari
and Mako?”
Ok we see Miho a bit cause
she’s giving orders but I feel like we barely spent anytime with our core
quintet during the final battle.
It’s as
if the supporting cast, amazing as they are, were given more time to shine than
the actual stars of Girls und Panzer.
It’s a common problem for most TV Anime with a huge cast (Bleach is a
prime example).
We do get to spend time
with Miho’s crew when everyones sad about moving away but I missed the banter
and the tone deaf sass of Mako.
Again,
the supporting allies are all great and they all deserve spinoffs of their
own…but I like my main team and thought their screentime should’ve been more
prominent.
Still, it’s hard to not come out of Girls und Panzer der
Film feeling any less than energized.
The action, animation and the return of the crazy and colorful
supporting cast provides a very fun experience.
The story feels recycled but without a proper antagonist for Miho and I
feel like her Tankery team got relegated to the background during the biggest
fight they’ve ever been in.
Can’t say I
didn’t dislike the movie either.
I was
invested in the rehashed plot, or at least the outcome of the characters, and
the FPS scenes left me in awe and feeling like I was on an actual roller
coaster ride.
In short, this is another
example of: if you loved the series, you’ll like the movie.
Don’t expect anything fresh from the plot,
just come for the insane action and the loveable cast riding those massive
behemoths into battle.
7/10
A good review dude, and yeah the film is...'hey did you watch the series? Let us do that in 90-mins.' As what usually happens here too I can't help but think about how the universe works. So, high school teams seem to use WWII era tanks. The college/university teams, post-war/early Cold War tanks. Is there a like a 'professional' or 'major league' level where they use late Cold War/Modern tanks? Might be fun to see.
ReplyDeleteIn fact, to address the issue you mentioned of the creators clearly wanting to play more with the other schools in the movie, if Girls un Panzer would work sort as an anthology thing? Maybe do a movie centered on the USA school or one on the Russian one, etc. Sort of lets them tell more tales and what not. Just a curious thought.
Also, glad to see the theme of each school again being sterotypes of their respective nation continue. And, Japan being a good sport, making fun of themselves with the Japanese tankery team. Rushing in, doing banzai charges, and not knowing how to fight without getting themselves all killed...fugitively speaking lol. And the Italian team with their sole crappy tankette cuz, poor Italy, you were the redheaded freckled step-child of WWII. And of course the Fins being awesome.
So, more silly fun with the absurd concept of anime girls and tanks.